[DISC] Projectiles can be thrown through water. Thoughts?

[WillLem]

Finally got around to actually being able to have a play around with the projectile skills properly. Even made a couple of levels.

Whilst playing through them, I realised that projectile skills can be thrown through water. I'm probably about 50/50 on whether this should be allowed. It could be seen to be thrown in front of the water rather than through it, for instance.

What do people think?

[jkapp76]

So far I think I like the projectiles passing through the water as is. Looks fine to me.

The only possible suggestion I have is to change the projectile color to blue as it passes through water. This would make it look clearly intentional and make the projectile appear under water as well.

[Proxima]

Spears passing through water is definitely the most natural behaviour, and anything else would feel strange.

Grenades could pass through or bounce off the surface or immediately explode -- I have no expectations coming from real-world experience as to which of those is most "natural". I would definitely be against them ceasing to exist with no effect, though!

[mobius]

passing through seems the most logical option for all of them [and simplest to avoid more complications/bugs].

[WillLem]

So far I think I like the projectiles passing through the water as is. Looks fine to me.

Spears passing through water is definitely the most natural behaviour, and anything else would feel strange.

passing through seems the most logical option for all of them [and simplest to avoid more complications/bugs].

Leaving it as it is would definitely be the easiest solution, so it's good to see support for that!

Grenades could ... immediately explode

I do like the "immediately explode" idea for Grenades. Any other thoughts on this?

The only possible suggestion I have is to change the projectile color to blue as it passes through water. This would make it look clearly intentional and make the projectile appear under water as well.

This is also a good idea, I agree that this would make it look a more intentional. We have to consider that the water could be any colour (or even multiple colours within the same graphic), so it would require getting the colour from the current area and then applying this as a hue-shift to the Spear/Grenade graphic in real-time. Difficult stuff, and I'm not entirely sure how well GR32 would handle this, tbh, but it might be worth a try at some point.

Some good ideas here.

[WillLem]

Since people seem happy enough with current behaviour, I'll leave it as it is rather than give the rendering even more work to do. Topic closed 21/7/23.