Hurt and Heal

[Clam]

Lemmings: 4
ONML: 4
Tribes: 4
Chronicles: 4 [+1 to create a 7-way tie http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/tongue.gif" alt=":P" title="Tongue" class="smiley" />]
L3D: 4
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 4 [-2 because it wouldn't record properly forcing IS to abandon the let's play http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" class="smiley" />]
Playstation: 5

[Proxima]

Regarding Hail 6(assuming Lix didn't turn the nuke to a flinging explosion)http://www.lemmingsforums.com/index.php?topic=12.msg1189#msg1189" class="bbc_link" target="_blank">the maximum itself should actually be relatively easy to determine with a small bit of level editing

I know; that's why I said it was a nightmare working out how to save the maximum  http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/tongue.gif" alt=":P" title="Tongue" class="smiley" />

=====
Lemmings: 5 [+1]
ONML: 4
Tribes: 2 [-2]
Chronicles: 4
L3D: 4
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 4
Playstation: 5

[ccexplore]

Back to another 7-way tie......

Lemmings: 4 [-1]
ONML: 4
Tribes: 3 [+1]
Chronicles: 4
L3D: 4
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 4
Playstation: 4 [-1]

[Simon]

Lemmings: 4
ONML: 5 [+1]
Tribes: 3
Chronicles: 4
L3D: 4
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 3 [-1] no easily identifiable teleporter pairs
Playstation: 3 [-1] strongest association with Sony

-- Simon

[Clam]

Lemmings: 4
ONML: 5
Tribes: 2 [-1] 2 points for Lemmings 2
Chronicles: 3 [-1] 3 points for Lemmings 3
L3D: 4
Paintball: 4 [oops fixed]
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 4 [+1] 4 points for PlayStation 4 (not that that's related to Lemmings)

[ccexplore]

Lemmings: 5 [+1] (um......ok I'm stretching here http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/XD.gif" alt=":XD:" title="XD" class="smiley" />, but spawned 5 general-release official "sequels/demos" still based on same game engine as original:  ONML, plus the 4 Xmas games released 1991-1994)
ONML: 4 [-1]  (4-letter acronym)
Tribes: 2
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 3 [-1] (3 dimensions)
Paintball: 4  [correcting typo in Clam's post]
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 4

[Proxima]

Lemmings: 6 [+1]
ONML: 4
Tribes: 0 [-2]
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 3
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 4

[Wafflem]

I want to try this!

ONML gets a point because of its challenging levels and no repeats (though Wild 1 and Wicked 6 are similar in layout).

If the Playstation is the PS3 version, I'll take away two points because there aren't enough levels, and there aren't enough Lemmings styles (though the remix of the Lemmings music in the main menu is very nice). If it's the PS1 version, well, I've never played it, but I heard that the Special Levels aren't there, so it still loses the two points.

Lemmings: 6
ONML: 5 [+1]
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 3
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 2 [-2]

[Mariachi Skeletron Prime]

Lemmings 3D just felt wierd. Lemmings isn't something that should be 3D, IMO.

Playstation was the first lemmings version I had, I don't care if it didn't have special levels, it was awesome.

Lemmings: 6
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 2 [-1]
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 3 [+1]

[Minim]

MSP, the rule here is that you take [-2] off one option rather than [-1]. Otherwise this game would take forever! Your [+1] was okay.

I'd assume in this case you want to take two off L3D? OK then. I'll keep with the flow and do that for you.

Lemmings: 6
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 1 [-1]
Paintball: 5 [+1]
Revolution: 3
Playstation: 1 [-2]

[Mariachi Skeletron Prime]

Whoops.  http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/embarrassed.gif" alt=":-[" title="Embarrassed" class="smiley" />
Thanks anyway.

[mobius]

I'm really surprised Paintball got so high. I thought not many people here even played that game.

Lemmings: 6
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 3
L3D: 0 [-1]
Paintball: 5
Revolution: 4 [+1]
Playstation: 0 [-1]

I'm sad to remove those two because I never played them and always wanted to.  http://www.lemmingsforums.com/Smileys/lemmings/cry.gif" alt=":'(" title="Cry" class="smiley" />

[Simon]

Lemmings: 5 (-)
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 4 (+)
Paintball: 4 (-) Your instincts are right. :-)
Revolution: 4

-- Simon

[Proxima]

Lemmings: 6 (+1)
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 2 (-2)
Paintball: 4
Revolution: 4

[NaOH]

I'm really surprised Paintball got so high.

I agree. This must be fixed.

Lemmings: 6
ONML: 5
Chronicles: 2
Paintball: 2 (-2)
Revolution: 5 (+1)